We write in response to a recently published opinion piece titled, “Organ donors save lives without trying,” published on April 30 in The Daily Toreador.

Thank you for covering the lifesaving topic of organ donation. LifeGift, the organ-procurement organization (OPO) serving Lubbock, and the Donate Life Texas donor registry appreciate the opportunity to explain our opposition to House Bill 1938.

While the bill is well intentioned, we believe the changes proposed by HB 1938 would decrease donations and lead to fewer Texans receiving the organ transplants they need to survive.

The current registry system allows people to make a donation decision, then register — or “opt in” — when they are ready. Most people opt in when getting a driver’s license.

The Texas registry is growing faster than any other state registry, and it includes nearly 50 percent of Texas adults and welcomes more than 1 million new registrants annually. The number of organs donated in Texas has increased by more than 35 percent in just five years.

HB 1938 proposes that all driver’s-license applicants be automatically registered unless they refuse, or “opt out.” While this idea may seem appealing to some, the risks and consequences are alarming.

First of all, registering should stay simple. The opt-out system proposed by HB 1938 would ask license applicants the question, “Would you like to refuse to register as an organ donor?”

This counterintuitive question requires a person to say “No” to agree to register, so a person’s response could be the opposite of what was intended.

The system also proposes that a person who does not answer the question at all would be added to the registry by default. We think donation should be a decision, not a default.

Second, the opt-out approach is controversial. A Gallup Poll found 57 percent of Texans oppose an opt-out system, primarily because it touches on ideas of privacy and government overreach. In fact, 27 percent said they would take steps to opt-out, regardless of their willingness to donate.

Also, a 2016 white paper by the United Network for Organ Sharing’s Ethics Committee reaffirmed its long-standing position that converting to an opt-out model is not ethically justified.

Third, support isn’t the same as a commitment. People can support organ donation and yet choose not to register. Though 90 percent of people say they support donation, not all are ready or feel informed enough to register.

The opt-out system proposed by HB 1938 forces driver’s-license applicants to record a decision, even if they aren’t ready.

Even worse, opting out would prevent a person’s family from being offered the option of donation after that person’s death.

Since 50-60 percent of donor cases rely on family consent, barring this option could mean thousands of fewer transplants each year.

And finally, the opt-in approach is universally accepted in the U.S. All 52 state- and territory-based donor registries in the U.S. are opt-in systems and function as a network.

This consistency supports national initiatives like the partnership with Apple that allows people to register using an iPhone. Ever wonder if Siri is an organ donor? Ask her.

As members of the donation community, we believe the current system offers the most effective way to continue increasing organ donation.

Research data prove that opt-in works, especially in Texas, which has one of the highest organ-donor rates in the world, exceeding every country with an opt-out registry system.

Our hope is that this information can help readers better understand the issue and why we oppose HB 1938, which seeks to abandon our current system that is clear, accepted and effective.

(1) comment

CCMrs

The Coach Bags On Sale winter, Jordan Schoenen and the Jordan Store advantages it pandora beads offered to nike shoes the Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher Irish army, passed Nike Air Max Goedkoop away, and the Air Jordan Retro Sale Duke of Schomberg, who, for several adidas outlet months, could have Yeezy Boost Sale Online offered but Ray Ban Sunglasses Online an ineffectual Nike Shoes Online opposition, was, Boty Nike Air through the vacillating policy ugg factory outlet of the nike jordan shoes king, and Nike Air Max Cheap the factious Oakley Sunglasses Cheap opposition of goedkope nike air max the Lords, chaussure basket homme spiritual Official Toms Shoes Outlet and temporal, in his Parliament, allowed to Nike Tn Requin Pas Cher take air force one pas cher the nike sneakers initiative in the renewal abercrombie and fitch store of hostilities. While he pressed the new pandora charms siege Air Max 90 of Charlemont Discount Ray Ban Sunglasses with renewed coach factory outlet online vigor, he Air Max Kopen dispatched 3,300 English Nike Shoes Sale Store and botas de futbol Enniskilleners, Negozi Pandora under the Ugg Pas Cher Femme command of Brigadier Yeezy Shoes Discount Marketplace Wolseley, to Hogan Outlet seize on Belturbet and Cavan, which were occupied Canada Goose Outlet through the winter new jordan releases by a converse store small force under Yeezy Black General Air Nike Wauchop, and to canada goose jacket outlet the pandora jewelry store relief nike tn pas cher of these adidas store positions, which were reebok running shoes considered of much importance, the Duke Air Max Pas Cher of Berwick was Original Ugg Boots ordered with Nike Store a force of 1,500 foot prada outlet and 200 horse. Air Max Femme Belturbet Soccer Boots Outlet nike had been ugg store the scene Nike Air Jordan 11 of many Cheap Michael Kors bitter fitflops sale uk conflicts Michael Kors Handbags Discount since the commencement Timberland Outlet of Nike Soccer Cleats Boots the rebellion, and had Michael Kors Outlet been taken suivre un envoi and retaken by the nike air jordan pas cher troops of each army huarache sneakers in turn, as Air max levně the Nike Factory Store tide retro jordans for cheap of Pandora Store Sale war fluctuated. chaussures nike pas cher Situated in Adidas Superstar Sale Online the Ray Ban Sunglasses Cheap midst of Air max dam a Uggs Pas Cher Soldes fertile Cheap Toms Outlet Store district, nfl store it was Ugg Pas Cher En France of Descuentos Nike much Adidas Neo Discount Sale advantage Doudoune Moncler Site Officiel in 23 IS BACK Store the way of supply. By its Kobe Shoes Nike possession, through the previous year, the Irish cheap uggs had Michael Kors Clearance been enabled to Yeezy Men hold Cheap Air Max the Enniskilleners in Ugg Outlet Online Store check Discount Air Max even ugg clearance after the disaster of Newtownbutler; newest lebron shoes and it was still Michael Kors hoped that, by holding Cheap Toms Shoes Outlet it, they could confine them TOMS For Sale to Adidas Soccer Cleats Cheap the more northern nike sb stefan janoski counties, and prevent their concentration round the Duke zapatilla adidas of Schomberg, or divert Canada Goose Womens Coats his attention from the capital.

Berwick, ADIDAS NMD SALE ON LINE on Nike Shox discount Sale receipt of the order, Nike Air Women proceeded by rapid marches, and arrived scarpe nike at Boost Yeezy Sale On Line Cavan, which is Ugg boots Sale about five miles Nike Outlet from Belturbet, late in the evening, nike schuhe günstig whence he sent Vans Black Sneakers orders to General Wauchop Scarpe Air Max to pandora outlet store throw Christian Louboutin Heels out pickets in the Air Max Sneakers direction Nike Air Sneakers of the enemy, and notify him of their Nike Air 90 earliest appearance. Owing to Discount Christian Louboutin Shoes the heavy rains that Nike Air Damen had fallen New Air Max 2017 through the night, Hugo Boss Sale this order was either totally neglected, Adidas Shoes Discount Marketplace or but carelessly observed; Cheap Nike Huarache and early in the morning, while Nike Online Store Berwick Adidas Originals Superstar took up Moncler Outlet Online his longchamp bags on sale march Cheap Michael Kors Tote Bag from chaussure Nike homme Cavan, Wolseley approached TOMS SHOES OUTLET as rapidly official NHL jerseys from womens nike air max the direction of Monaghan; moncler jacket sale each with the Nike Air Pas Cher intention of Pandora Store occupying Uggs For Cheap a mud fort which commanded the TOMS OUTLET town. Both forces, each unapprised of the scarpe hogan outlet design Moncler Outlet Store of the canada goose jackets on sale other, met Adidas Originals Stan Smith in the intrenchments, christian louboutin outlet and a fierce Chaussure Nike Air Max Pas Cher conflict followed. Wolseley cheap nike air max was driven Boutique Ugg from vans shoe store the Canada Goose Outlet fort and through zapatos de futbol nike the billige nike sko adjoining coppice Canada goose dam in Moncler Sale great confusion, but Colonel MacGeoghaghen being killed, Stone Island Outlet and General Nugent and Moncler Jackets Discount Marketplace several officers wounded, their troops Nike Shox Cheap became panic-stricken, "and, Nike Zapatos in zapatillas running a moment," says Berwick, "from Jordan Shoes Air being conquerors, Cheap Air Max Trainers we became nike air max running shoes conquered." cheap uggs for women Wolseley nike sportschuhe lost 300 Discount TOMS men, Doudoune Moncler Femme Pas Cher and Nike Air Huarache For Sale Berwick 500; the nike air fort Jordan Sneakers For Sale was evacuated Chaussure Air Max as toms sale a Nike Roshe Run Sale consequence; Pandora Store the Irish fell Toms Factory Outlet back louboutin heels to nike mercurial soccer cleats Cavan, Adidas Superstar which Cheap Real Jordans they new yeezy shoes shortly after abandoned; and hogan scontate Schomberg, being relieved of further apprehension Nike Pas Cher Femme from that direction, and being Nike Shoes Discount Marketplace strengthened by his native zapatillas nike baratas auxiliaries, turned günstige nike schuhe his undivided Pandora Official Website attention to the siege UGG BOOTS FOR WOMEN of Charlemont.

toms shoes outlet

PPST 2017.5.19

Report Add Reply

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Post a comment
Stop watching this discussion.